We analyzed 29 negative reviews from the top 5 Whiskey Log apps on the App Store. Here's what users hate most.
Ranked by frequency — how often each complaint appears in negative reviews.
62% of negative reviews mention this issue.
"It's been over 2 months since I've requested to liquidate my account over $12,000. After reaching out and calling 3 times, I still haven't gotten any response."
"They make the selling process impossible so you keep paying their stupid fee"
48% of negative reviews mention this issue.
"Fees are so high that any gains you see are used to cover them."
"Cool concept, but in reality their fees eat up any actual returns. Had my money invested for 3 years and ended up in the red."
45% of negative reviews mention this issue.
"I have had my wine for over 3 years and my dashboard shows a 20% return so far. As soon as I listed my wine for sale the return dropped to -30%"
"about a year in, I have to invest more money because they've already lost over 5% in value for my account"
34% of negative reviews mention this issue.
"As mentioned by other users, it's difficult to get your investment back. The bid ask spreads are huge so no one is paying their theoretical market prices."
"if theres no liquidity for the wine you buy you have no option bu"
31% of negative reviews mention this issue.
"I tried to reach out to Support and they were of no help"
"I have never called support and been connectef with an agent."
28% of negative reviews mention this issue.
"The app is just ok. There is not a lot you can do on the app. Extremely basic point and click."
"app does not work well, logs you out every time"
Design and usability issues driving negative reviews.
Session management issues force repeated logins, making the app frustrating to use regularly
"app does not work well, logs you out every time"
Hidden fee structure with surprise overdraft charges without warning
"They charge fees originally from a cash balance and then charge an overdraft fee without warning that you need to add to the cash before charging it."
Dashboard shows misleading returns that don't match actual sale prices
"I have had my wine for over 3 years and my dashboard shows a 20% return so far. As soon as I listed my wine for sale the return dropped to -30%"
Get the complete Whiskey Log market intelligence report — including missing features, pricing insights, build recommendations, and competitor weaknesses.
View Full Report — $9.9930-day money-back guarantee