An honest comparison based on real user reviews. Both are popular Marketplace apps — but which one do users complain about less?
Search algorithm completely broken, hiding seller inventory and destroying sales for long-time users
"I've been selling on Poshmark since 2015. It used to be such an amazing platform. This is where I do 95% of my business. I used to make SO much profit on this app. Sales have completely depleted within the last few years"
"I HAVE NOT MADE A SALE SINCE JULY2025! I've been on Poshmark for over 6 years. It used to be a good selling app until Jan. 2025."
No protection against inactive sellers and unhelpful support system that takes too long to respond
"they do not filter sellers correctly so you will get inactive sellers and it's up to you to find out if they are active or not. Mercari does very little to protect you from inactive sellers"
"Mercari health center and support system needs a lot of work their employees don't know what they're doing. They take super long to review help request."
Complete analysis of all Marketplace apps, including missing features, pricing insights, and what to build instead.
View Marketplace Report — $9.99